Category: Polemics & Exchanges

Home Polemics & Exchanges
Shameless Defenses
Post

Shameless Defenses

Congratulations to Taki for achieving what seemed to be impossible: transforming the effete, amoral boob FDR into a sympathetic figure (“Little Yellow Bastards,” Under the Black Flag, April).  Taki’s celebration of early-to-mid-20th-century Japanese military traditions and the heroic unshackling of Japan’s economy from those nefarious usurers was understandable.  His failure to mention other significant activities...

Post

Macmillan’s Legacy

In “That Special Relationship” (Vital Signs, February), Christopher Sandford compares British Prime Minister Harold Macmillan’s attitudes toward communism with those of President John F. Kennedy.  I hope that Mr. Sandford’s upcoming book on the subject will provide some crucial historical context by discussing Macmillan’s role in the forced repatriation of Slovenian freedom fighters (Domobranci) to...

Post

Final Thoughts

Catholics and Protestants sometimes remind me of Captain Quint and Chief Brody on board the Orca.  While they are at odds with each other, a monstrous thing is circling their beat-up old boat and threatening to swallow them whole, to paraphrase Quint.  Pretty soon we mackerel-snappers and our Protestant brethren may very well find ourselves in...

Post

Polemics on Polemics

When I delivered Liberty: The God That Failed into the hands of my publisher, I did so with no little trepidation.  Supported entirely by Protestant, secular academic, and other non-Catholic sources, including the work of numerous historians of the first rank, its detailed, 700-page counternarrative of the rise and fall of what the moderns call...

Post

Numquam et Nusquam

Scott P. Richert (“Returning to Reality,” Views, December) says he’s a Catholic.  He doesn’t write like one. What distinguishes Catholics is possession of a Deposit of Faith given 2,000 years ago.  No, saith Richert.  What’s important is a “lived relationship with the Risen Christ from which those doctrines flow . . . ”  Lived relationship? ...

Post

I’ll Take My Sit

Because it’s reasonable to assume that Gerald Russello (“The Agrarian Burden,” Reviews, October) is highly knowledgeable of his chosen subject, the Southern Agrarians, I must conclude that his avoidance of their intellectual hypocrisy (or worse) is by choice and not by accident. I’ll Take My Stand was written by a dozen academics, most comfortably ensconced...

Along for the Ride
Post

Along for the Ride

I thoroughly enjoyed Roger D. McGrath’s account of the Southern California Norton Owners Club journey along Old Route 66 (Correspondence, September).  He mentions that his home is near the Rock Store, which immediately brought up memories of my old stomping grounds.  I grew up in the west end of the San Fernando Valley, in Woodland...

Post

Reason and War

I am grateful to George McCartney for his articulate and fascinating review of Copperhead (“Reason’s Enemy,” In the Dark, September).  Unlike most reviewers, he concentrates (at least this time) on the plot, theme, historicity, characters, and atmosphere, instead of the usual pointless ramblings about the previous work and personal history of the director, or technical...

Post

King George’s Tax

A few points on “Of Presidents and Guns,” by Egon Richard Tausch (Vital Signs, June). After the French and Indian War the British crown gave George Washington some large land grants in Western Pennsylvania for his service.  The Indians (part of the Iroquois Confederation) living there didn’t think the British king had any authority to...

Post

Running Numbers

In William J. Quirk’s essay “How Goldman Sachs Is Swindling America’s Cities” (American Proscenium, July), Professor Quirk evidences profound misunderstanding of what is happening in an interest-rate swap. An interest-rate swap for a borrower is a way to remove or reduce interest-rate risk from a transaction.  This was described adequately in Professor Quirk’s article.  The...

Post

Iron Lady

Englishman Michael Stenton’s article “Margaret Thatcher” (Correspondence, June) never once mentions Thatcher’s hatred of the Irish, especially Catholics, which caused her to commit war crimes in Northern Ireland—crimes for which she should have been tried at The Hague. These include gladly allowing ten IRA hunger strikers to starve themselves to death at Long Kesh prison...

Post

Slavery, or Not

Joseph E. Fallon’s assertion (in “The North’s Southern Cash Cow,” Vital Signs, June) that the reason the South seceded “was the tariff, not slavery” is simply wrong.  The loss of revenue from the American System of tariffs may have been one of the reasons the North waged war against the South.  But the South’s main...

Post

The Other Dylan

I enjoyed Dr. Thomas Fleming’s “Topsy-Turvy” (Perspective, June).  But I thought his gratuitous denigration of Jakob Dylan both unnecessary and ill informed.  I am not some Jakob Dylan “fanboy”; in fact, the only album I had owned is the Wallflowers’ 1996 Bringing Down the Horse, which is a fine piece of pop music.  Dr. Fleming’s...

Post

Entitlement Devolution

As a friend of many years, who has often disagreed with Thomas Fleming, I especially appreciated his perspicacious article, “Topsy-Turvy” (Perspective), in the June issue of Chronicles.  For in that article, amid his varied historical analogies and references, he prompted me not only to reconsider in a new light the formal constitutional language of Soviet...

Post

Learning Lincoln

With reference to Clyde Wilson’s “Civil War Cinema” (Vital Signs, May), I have to admit that I liked the movie Lincoln, in spite of its 21st-century sensibilities.  Still, even I thought it was straining credulity to the breaking point when the black soldier started lecturing Lincoln on the various racial inequities in the Union Army. ...

Post

No Apologies for Chávez

Having been married to a Venezuelan and a resident of Caracas for nearly 25 years, I was extremely disappointed in Justin Raimondo’s “A Revolutionary Who Wasn’t” (Between the Lines, May).  Hugo Chávez was indeed a revolutionary, from his initial attempt at a coup d’état in 1992 through his interminable hours-long speeches, his friendship with and support of...

Post

Assault Weapons Needed?

I did learn some things from Aaron D. Wolf’s piece “Adam Lanza’s America” (American Proscenium, February).  But there is a glaring, unsupported assertion.  How do we know that “the next Adam Lanza” would for sure try to kill children with a knife, or a can of gasoline?  A semiautomatic weapon is so much easier.  And...

Post

Stealth Candidates

I have no desire to defend President George H.W. Bush or his execrable appointment of David Souter to the Supreme Court, but I was confused by the chronology of the Turnock v. Ragsdale case laid out by Scott P. Richert in the February issue (“Robert Bork, R.I.P.,” Cultural Revolutions).  In December 1989, when that case...

Post

Ugly Realities

I was thrilled to see that Aaron D. Wolf was poised to address the “ugly reality” behind the murder-suicide perpetrated by Kansas City Chiefs player Jovan Belcher (“Handgun Culture, Cultural Revolutions, January).  Unfortunately, instead of confronting the real problem, Mr. Wolf went on a puritanical tirade against cohabitation. The “ugly reality” that the mainstream media...

Post

Duking It Out

Bravo to Roger D. McGrath for his perceptive defense of John Wayne against liberal snipers (“John Wayne and World War II,” Sins of Omission, December).  As Sergeant Stryker said to Pfc. Benny Ragazzi after he called up a Sherman tank to blast a Japanese pillbox in Sands of Iwo Jima (1949), “Ya did all right.”...

Post

We Happy Few

I am a longtime subscriber and have always enjoyed your happy-warrior approach to our absurd political and social situation.  However, I must commend you all for the November (“The Failure of Democracy”) and December (“Classical Liberalism: Enemy of Christianity”) issues.  The articles on democracy and liberalism were absolutely brilliant.  They were all insightful, extremely well...

Post

The Polish Question

In his review of Roosevelt’s Lost Alliances: How Personal Politics Helped Start the Cold War, by Frank Costigliola (“Diplomacy, Good and Bad,” December), George W. Liebmann writes, “Czechoslovakia had outflanked Poland in 1939 . . . ”  Fascinating.  It is especially fascinating in view of the fact that the Munich Pact of 1938 had dismembered...

Post

Laudas Me, Culpant Me

Christopher Sandford’s laudatory biographical article on Field Marshal Bernard Montgomery (“The Soldier’s Soldier,” Biography, October) concentrated mainly on Montgomery’s victory at the Second Battle of El Alamein.  It does not mention that Britain’s Eighth Army outnumbered the Axis forces almost two to one, 220,000 versus 115,000 troops, and 1,100 to 559 tanks.  In addition, the...

Post

Don’t Call It Ugly

When reading Prof. James O. Tate’s review of Glock: The Rise of America’s Gun (“Caring About the Glock,” September), I kept hoping that he would have recited the key statistic that makes guns so beloved and embedded in America’s history and culture: Each year guns are used some two million times to prevent a crime...

Post

Jimmy’s Last Stand

It will perhaps not become me to quibble with a review (“Little Jimmy Rides Again,” August) that says my new book, James Madison and the Making of America, may justly be “billed as the new standard on its subject.”  Yet I hope that Chronicles readers will accept a reply to Clyde Wilson’s very amusing, insightful...

Post

Always Low Vices?

Has Mark Brennan any evidence of Wal­mart getting monopoly privileges in the United States, as he claimed in “Anarcho-Tyranny Versus . . . Walmart?” (American Proscenium, July)?  Is there any evidence for the truly grotesque accusation that Central American sex slaves end up in Walmart stores north of the border (or south of it for,...

The Slavery Issue
Post

The Slavery Issue

I am writing to register a complaint about Clyde Wilson’s review “Neither Devil nor Mystery” (June).  My complaint might be unfounded, which I hope it is, since I have found Chronicles to be one of the only magazines to publish excellent and thoughtful articles about unpopular but important topics.  But if my complaint turns out...

Post

Grand Theses

I fear that Chilton Williamson’s column in the June issue (“Neither ‘Gay’ Nor ‘Marriage,’” What’s Wrong With the World) loses its point about a third of the way through—and conveys an uncharitable impression of the author that I know to be untrue.  While the gay issue often provokes conservatives to have an instantaneous emotional reaction, perhaps...

Post

Don’t Blame Iran

Leon Hadar, in his article “Bombing Iran” (Cultural Revolutions, April), could not be further from the truth when he states, “A radical regime is projecting its military power, trying to destabilize the pro-American governments in the Middle East, threatening the state of Israel, and aiming to achieve regional supremacy.” Unlike Israel, Iran has not invaded...

Who Rode the Phaeton?
Post

Who Rode the Phaeton?

I prefer to believe that there is something I don’t know about Greek mythology than that both Dr. John Willson, in “The End of a Myth” (Views, April), and the Chronicles copyeditor could mistakenly confuse Icarus with Phaeton.  Are they really—at least sometimes—the same person?  My Edith Hamilton seems to imply that Ovid is our...

Post

Scot Free

In “An Unjustified War” (Views, February), Srdja Trifkovic brilliantly summarizes the Iraq war as being “a disaster for the United States, for the Iraqis, and for the stability of the region.  All putative justifications were based on outright lies or gross errors of judgment.  It was an unjust and unjustifiable war.” Given the truth of...

Post

State’s Wrongs

Chilton Williamson, Jr.’s column “Pragmatic Destruction” (What’s Wrong With the World, December 2011) attacks American democracy with a vengeance.  He seems to be bothered by the fact that Southern blacks were “freed” (his quotation marks) by civil-rights laws through the negation of “states’ rights” (my quotation marks).  I don’t see how restricting a certain class...

Post

Feeling Squanto’s Pain

Would you please edit Tom Landess (“Communities and Strangers,” Views, December 2011) for historical accuracy?  Such a serious libel of anyone, even a dead man, distracts me from the argument. Squanto could not have betrayed his original tribe even if he had wanted to; they were already extinct when he finally got back from England. ...

What Matters?
Post

What Matters?

The November 2011 issue of Chronicles has a major problem on page five. In “Aborted Economy” (American Proscenium), John C. Seiler, Jr., writes, and the editors boldly highlight in a pull-quote, a statement about “the 1973 class of ‘fetal matter,’ as the pro-aborts call them.” I have reread the article several times looking for support...

On Blinkeredness
Post

On Blinkeredness

The Cold War rages on for Christie Davies (“Islam and Breivik’s Bombs,” News, October).  He even referenced the “evil” Russian/communist in drawing a bead on the “evil” Muslim. And what evils are the Muslims of Europe guilty of?  Davies is upset that women are expected to wear headscarves (read: act modestly) in Muslim neighborhoods, a...

Post

Erase Publica

It is impossible not to agree with Chilton Williamson, Jr.’s deep insight into the nature of modern democracies (“Contradiction and Collapse,” What’s Wrong With the World, September), all the more as it is enhanced by clear and rigorous phrasing. I have, however, an issue—maybe only semantic—with his initial assertion that there may be such a...

Post

Institutes of Ignorance

I am not sure who is more ignorant of John Calvin: Robert H. Nelson, who wrote The New Holy Wars, or Tobias Lanz, who reviewed it (“Calvinism Without God,” August).  Since I haven’t read Mr. Nelson’s book, I will address Mr. Lanz’s review. I was more than a little taken aback to read that “Calvin...

Of Martyrs and Men
Post

Of Martyrs and Men

George McCartney (“The First and Final Command,” In the Dark, June) seems to believe that the Trappists of Tibhirine died as Christian martyrs.  I do not.  If the film he reviewed, Of Gods and Men, portrays them accurately, they prayed in the local mosque regularly; in other words, they repeatedly and publicly worshiped a false...

Community Revisited
Post

Community Revisited

Congratulations to Ray Olson for his review of Kings Row (“Kings Row Revisited,” Vital Signs, June), book and film, and his insight into how the movie slights the book’s theme of community.  There is a big subject here.  Community has been central to Southern literature.  The community—Yoknapatawpha—is the true central character of Faulkner’s fiction, as...

Post

Who’s Number One?

I was puzzled by Chilton Williamson, Jr.’s “Who Cares Who’s Number One?” (What’s Wrong with the World, May).  No reasonable person can disagree with his contempt for our country’s endemic America Number One philosophy, especially when we routinely fall so short.  But given the decadent reality of life in most of Europe these days, it’s...

Post

All That Jazz

I greatly enjoyed and appreciate Tony Outh­waite’s recent tribute to George Shearing (“No Apologies for Jazz,” Cultural Revolutions, April).  Well done. In late 1954 or early 1955 I twice traveled from my assignment at Chanute Air Force Base in Rantoul, Illinois, to the University at Champaign-Urbana to hear some live jazz. The first time, it...

Post

Expanding Minds

Thomas Fleming’s “To Save One Child” (Beyond the Revolution, March) reminds me why everyone who still values a reasoned and ethical perspective on family values, and many other aspects of contemporary living in America, should read Chronicles. After pointing out how easily a well-intentioned individual, professing a spiritual nature, confuses values with virtues, Fleming then...

Post

Forgotten Fighters

I was pleasantly surprised to see an article about a boxer in Chronicles.  Roger D. McGrath’s “The Fighting Marine: Gene Tunney” (Sins of Omission, January) describes a great champion and an admirable American who should be better remembered.  Dr. McGrath alludes to Tunney’s fights with Harry Greb, a five-fight series that is also unfortunately forgotten. ...

Post

More Neocon Follies

I have received only one copy of your filthy magazine, but that is enough. I based my decision to subscribe to Chronicles on an ad you mailed me.  The ad made it appear that Chronicles is a serious, conservative publication similar to those I already subscribe to: the Wall Street Journal, Human Events, National Review,...

Post

Learning From Mises?

I read with great interest R. Cort Kirkwood’s review of Christopher Ferrara’s The Church and the Libertarian (“Anarcho-Utopia Revisited”) in the November issue of Chronicles.  Mr. Kirkwood does a great service by pointing out the pitfalls, from a Catholic perspective, of some of the thinking of some adherents of the Austrian School. While Mr. Kirkwood...

Post

Who’s To Blame?

I thoroughly dispute Mark G. Brennan’s thesis in “The Borrowers’ Crisis” (Vital Signs, November) that it was the borrowers who were mostly to blame for “the crisis.” How did the party-of-the-first-part—those lending and mortgage-financing institutions—get away with making loans to uninvestigated potential borrowers, uncollateralized borrowers?  Where were the state and local regulators?  Where were the...

Post

Pro-WikiLeaks

In “What Consequences?” (Cultural Revolutions, October), R. Cort Kirkwood stated (with regard to the WikiLeaks case) that Army Pfc. Bradley “Manning is a traitor.  He deserves the firing squad.”  Just the same as a German soldier would have been executed as a traitor for revealing documents about the Nazi concentration camps. Mr. Kirkwood, I am...

Post

To Arms!

Concerning Scott P. Richert’s reservations about secession, as expressed in the October Rockford Files (“To Secede or Succeed?”): Maybe “many proponents of secession seem reluctant to consider” some of the alleged drawbacks of secession.  There certainly are risks.  The architects of unitary nationalism weren’t dummies.  The grants economy, the safety net, Social Security, and the...

Post

Numbering More

I love to argue controversial issues—and even argue with myself.  On occasion I’ve found both of me wrong.  I strongly dislike having my position misrepresented, though.  Allen Mendenhall (“Atomic Anniversary,” News, August), in arguing against the use of the bombs at Hiroshima and Nagasaki, mentions my piece on the subject (Sins of Omission, July 2009)...

Post

Marxist Beaches

Although I know well all the disclaimers—a writer’s statement does not reflect the journal’s official position, a writer is entitled to his opinion in a “free” society, etc.—I must express my dismay at Justin Raimondo’s gratuitous and mean-spirited insult against a people who, at least on many social and not a few political issues, are...